Thinking Geographically
The jump from GCSE
to A level geography is a big one- even larger with the reformed AS levels.
Where GCSE requires the memorisation of definitions and systems, AS level
requires you to develop a new form of geographical thinking. The subject moves
from standalone modules, to a group of interconnected concepts. Over the year,
I only scratched the surface of this level of thinking and this document sums
up the 4 skills required to start the development of the new mind set.
The first concept
that must be understood is the fundamental difference between a space and a
place. Tuan (1977) described space as a geographical, physical, location- a
grid reference. A space, when paired with meaning, becomes a place. Now
'meaning' is a rather vague term- meanings are perceptions, individual to the
person talking. In this sense, there is no one way to define a place. Massey
(1994), agreed to an extent- she agreed with the definition of place, however,
she depicted space as something equally dynamic. She said that space was not
defined by physical borders- for instance, take London. Some may only perceive
the city centre as London. Others will decide that the arterial roads like the
M3 are a part of the city. I think that by combining the 2 theories, we can
attempt to clarify a definition. Massey's definition of space ties with Yuan's
on place- place is a space with flexible borders; a location that develops an
identity with individual perceptions. Whatever definition is chosen, I maintain
that place is not to be defined, but rather experienced.
The skill of
synoptic thinking is touched upon by other subjects at GCSE, such as in Science
and English, and geography is no different. Geographers look at the world from
scales- local to global. Jackson (1996) described this as 'zooming in and
zooming out'. However, a large part of geographical thinking comes from the
ability to link the different scales. The relationship between local and global
geographies was discussed by Smith's (1993) example of homelessness in New
York; however, I think a more current example could be President Trumps
decision to pull out of the Paris agreement. The change made was a on a
national scale, but the impacts will be both global and local. By continuing
with their lack of carbon monitoring, global warming will be exacerbated which
has countless global impacts- from international droughts, to local crop
failure. By learning to automatically link geographies together, you will be
able to form your own opinions on the impacts of decisions.
Finally, when
analysing some human geographies, distance becomes more than the physical,
measured value. The perceived distance is often more important than the
physical distance in an age where resources can be passed thousands of miles in
a couple of hours. The perception of distance is affected by many things, but
the increased efficiency of transport is one of them. Harvey (1998) discusses
the idea of 'time space compression (or convergence)'. By making places more
accessible, the perceived distance is diminished. For instance, the HS2 rail
link reduce the time from London to Liverpool by 40 minutes- quicker to get to,
and hence appearing closer. This impacts other geographies, which are to be
studied in their own rights.
In conclusion,
geographical thinking requires an open and receptive mind. In this subject you
will learn that places are more than locations, everything is connected, and
everything is only as far away as it seems.
Comments
Post a Comment